As we usher in the new year, climate change remains one of the most pressing challenges of our time. However, the journey to meaningful climate action is fraught with complexities, as highlighted by recent developments in the European asset management industry. A detailed report by the Financial Times sheds light on how political pressures and regulatory hurdles are reshaping the landscape of climate-focused investing, even in regions traditionally seen as leaders in sustainability.
The Chilling Effect: A Global Trend Reaches Europe
In recent months, European asset managers have exhibited growing caution in publicly supporting climate initiatives. This shift mirrors trends in the United States, where heightened political scrutiny and legal challenges have dampened enthusiasm for environmental, social, and governance (ESG) investments.
Natasha Landell-Mills, Head of Stewardship at Sarasin & Partners, aptly describes the situation:
"The chilling effect from the increasing politicization of climate change in the US is certainly spreading to Europe and beyond. The danger is that we end up harming ourselves and future generations by pulling back."
This chilling effect has tangible consequences. For instance, European support for climate resolutions at annual meetings has dropped significantly, from 84% in 2022 to 69% in 2024, according to FTI Consulting. Such a decline underscores the growing hesitancy among asset managers to openly champion climate causes.
Balancing Public Pressure and Private Action
Despite a more subdued public stance, many European asset managers continue to prioritize climate action behind the scenes. These firms recognize the financial and reputational risks of ignoring climate change, even as they navigate the political backlash.
Stephen Beer, Head of Responsible Investment Strategic Relationships at Legal & General Investment Management (LGIM), emphasizes the industry's evolving approach:
"We are talking about business strategies, progress towards transition, decisions that companies have to make. And that is exactly where we want to be in conversations with companies."
This behind-the-scenes focus reflects a strategic pivot. By avoiding public controversies, asset managers aim to maintain their climate commitments while safeguarding their business interests.
Regulatory and Methodological Challenges
European asset managers face significant hurdles in meeting their climate pledges. Upcoming EU regulations, set to take effect in 2025, will require financial institutions to disclose progress against voluntary climate and biodiversity targets. These requirements, coupled with the slow pace of the global energy transition, have made it increasingly difficult to achieve net-zero ambitions.
A Paris-based financier encapsulates the industry's frustration:
"It’s a bit demotivating to be set an incredibly tough goal with ineffective ways of getting there."
The reliance on relatively new methodologies for carbon financial accounting further complicates the situation, leading to internal pushback against ambitious sustainability targets.
The Role of Asset Owners and Pension Funds
While asset managers tread cautiously, European pension funds and other asset owners are doubling down on their climate efforts. Jon Johnson, CEO of the Danish pension fund PKA, highlights their leadership role:
"We as asset owners will have to take the lead right now on driving action on climate from the finance sector. If we keep on pushing for the green transformation, I am sure from a business perspective, asset managers will want to keep that growth."
This dynamic creates a push-and-pull scenario, where asset managers must balance client demands for sustainability with the political and regulatory challenges they face.
Why Climate Action Remains Non-Negotiable
Despite the challenges, the fundamentals of climate change remain unchanged. Ignoring its risks is not an option. As Sonja Laud, Chief Investment Officer at LGIM, points out:
"Climate is a financially material aspect in understanding a company’s future success, and we will continue to include it in our investment process."
Landell-Mills echoes this sentiment:
"Ultimately, the fundamentals haven’t changed. Climate change is still happening. Ignoring the risks doesn’t make them go away. But it delays action to tackle them."
Looking Ahead: A Call to Action
The European asset management industry's cautious approach to climate action serves as a stark reminder of the complex interplay between politics, regulation, and corporate responsibility. However, it also highlights the resilience of those committed to addressing climate change.
As we step into 2025, let this serve as a call to action for businesses, investors, and individuals alike. Climate change is not just an environmental issue—it is an economic, social, and geopolitical challenge that demands collective effort. Together, we can navigate these complexities and drive meaningful change for a sustainable future.
Thank you for reading!
